I have just finished reading Audrey Niffenegger's The Time Traveler's Wife, and my feelings are mixed. On one hand, it is a very engaging novel, a page-turner, an interesting blend of science fiction and romance. At different times, the story made me hold my breath, envy, smile, and (almost) cry. There is one big "BUT" though.
To put it simply, I would have enjoyed the book much, much more if the characters were, well, nicer people. I don't see how casual use of drugs, getting drunk, and (SPOILER!) sleeping with one's best friend's boyfriend/spouse on two separate occasions add to the plot. I'm not trying to ignore reality here - I know that a lot of people practice destructive behavior, but I am against making it look normal. The numeral occurrences of the "f-word" and other vulgarities seem unjustified as well.
Also, there is (in my humble opinion) a major plot issue: until Henry and Clare meet in real time, he leads an absolutely selfish yet self-destructive life. He is the kind of person I would pity, but wouldn't want to have anything to do with. And then Clare comes along, and he suddenly turns into a nearly angelic being. Just like that. "I don't believe it!" - as Stanislavski would have said.
All in all, it was a good read, but not something I would purchase, want a hypothetical teenage daughter to read, or recommend to my pastor's wife.
Thanks for your thoughts. I haven't read the book or seen the movie, but I was thinking I would like to read the book before I see the movie (I usually like to do that). Maybe I'll just see the movie. :) Have a great day.
ReplyDeleteI usually prefer reading the book before seeing the movie as well. In this case, however, I saw the movie first and should have stopped there!
ReplyDeletejust found your lovely blog through a whole lotta love:) so happy i did! i've never read this book, though i saw the movie simply because i think rachel mcadams is so excellent. i like that your review was critical and informative. so often, book reviews just give the positives, and rarely dig into the parts that you just.didn't.like. this was a breath of fresh air:) thanks!
ReplyDeleteThank you :) I have a tendency to tell it like it is, which is not a good thing, really.
ReplyDeleteLike I said, I liked the movie much better than the book.